Friday, December 16, 2011

A Love Birds' Guide to a Christmas Cookie Exchange

As a follow-up to yesterday's post I wanted to share more details about throwing a Christmas Cookie Exchange and my all-time favorite Christmas cookie recipe.

I vividly remember the first cookie exchange I went to as a child. It was actually a party my mom was invited to, but I came along. I remember seeing piles and piles of cookies everywhere and being completely excited and overwhelmed at the same time. I think this was one of the first times I tried buckeyes, an Ohio specialty, and I soon became obsessed with them.

The first cookie exchange I hosted was in 2007 when I first moved to NYC. I didn't have a lot of attendees and in 2008 when I was living in Queens while engaged I skipped having it and picked it back up when I returned to Harlem in 2009 after I got married. That time I did it as a brunch and made homemade buttermilk waffles topped with fresh whipped cream and blueberries but again had a poor turnout. Finally in 2010 I think things started going better because Lil Love Bird arrived and everyone was excited to see her! Having a prize for best cookie helped too. I repeated the prize this year. 

So quickly (before we get to the amazing recipe!), here are my basics for throwing a Christmas Cookie Exchange:
  • Timing - do it mid-afternoon so people have time to sleep in and it doesn't interfere with brunch or dinner; also 2nd Saturday of December tends to work for me and my friends
  • Balance - make sure to offer salty/healthy snacks to balance all the sugar; I like low-salt pretzels, potato chips and veggies and dip
  • Allow store-bought cookies - so many people are deterred because they don't bake so I reiterate in the Evite that store-bought cookies are ok (in fact a store-bought cookie won this year; it was a "monster cookie" from here)
  • Provide take-home containers - I think it's best to have the cookies laid out either in original packaging (if guests bring cute containers) or arrange them on your own tiers/cake stands with labels for guests to take at will (not everyone likes every cookie!); one year I used tins from Michaels but as the attendee list has become longer I do winter-themed bags and boxes from either there or The Container Store
  • Entertain - have fun music from Pandora and/or streaming Christmas movies in the background to add to the festivities
Now on to the recipe . . .

When I was a teen my mom made these Buried Cherry Cookies (her recipe was via a BHG cookbook, but I found the same recipe at My mom's always had the most elaborate assortment of Christmas cookies she'd bake every year that I remember from when I was little, but the later-introduction of the Buried Cherry Cookies stopped me dead in my tracks - they were life changing! SERIOUSLY. The best part about the cookies is the cherry in the middle. I know not everyone likes maraschino cherries but something about the fudginess of the cookie and the chocolate spooned on top (flavored with cherry juice) makes them so delicious.


1 (10 oz.) jar maraschino cherries (about 48)
1 1/2 c. flour
1/2 c. unsweetened cocoa powder
1/4 tsp. baking soda
1/4 tsp. baking powder
1/4 tsp. salt
1/2 c. butter
1 c. sugar
1 egg
1 1/2 tsp. vanilla
1 (6 oz.) pkg. semi sweet chocolate pieces
1/2 c. sweetened condensed milk
Drain cherries and reserve juice. Stir together flour, cocoa, soda, powder and salt. In a large mixer bowl beat butter until soft. Add sugar and beat until fluffy. Add egg and vanilla; beat well. Add flour mixture and blend well.

Shape dough into 1" balls. Place about 2" apart on ungreased cookie sheets. Press down center of each with your thumb. Place a cherry in each cookie.


In small saucepan combine chocolate chips and sweetened condensed milk. Cook over low heat until chocolate is melted. Stir in 4 teaspoons of the reserved cherry juice. Spoon 1 teaspoon frosting over each cherry, swirling to completely cover cherry.


Bake at 350 degrees for about 10 minutes. Remove to racks and cool. Makes about 48.*

*In my experience this recipe never yields 48 - I have to double it to get that many!

If you end up making them please let me know how you like them! 

What is your all time favorite Christmas cookie?


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...